
[Post first published on Patreon]
Straining yogurt into cheese is a practice as old as dairying itself, found across cultures under many names—labneh, chakka, strained curd, and more. The method is beautifully simple: salt and hang until thickened, then shape or serve. This version, dubbed dream cheese by those in poetic moods, takes its cues from historical techniques but invites a fantasy twist through the addition of herbs, blossoms, or color. Whether packed into cloth molds or spooned onto flatbread, it’s an ideal way to use fresh milk and preserve a touch of early summer.
Light as cloud fluff and faintly tangy, this creamy delicacy is rumored to form when milk is left to rest beneath the silver glow of a waxing moon. Sweet herbs or crushed petals may be folded in, though some prefer it plain, served with honeycomb and wafer-thin bread at twilight feasts.
For my recipe, I folded into the yogurt the contents of a single blue butterfly tea bag, which gave the resulting cheese an amazing swirled blue color that just feels kinda magical. A bit of salt
This has been one of the most successful endeavors in my cheese-making binge, although I’ve learned a lot from my other mistakes, as well! For that, I’m delving deep into David Asher’s book on Natural Cheesemaking.
I’m smitten with this super easy recipe, and it makes for a dead sexy bagel in the morning, with that blue swirl of color and a little honey drizzled on top. I’m heartily tempted to pencil this in for the Adventurer’s Cookbook, as well. Perhaps in the Elven section? Poppy and Nibs might first encounter it after helping a half-sylvan apiarist gather pollen from moonbloom flowers—an act of service repaid with a twilight feast and this dream-laced delicacy.
Gosh I love what I do!
Recipe for Twilight Dream Cheese
Makes: About 1 cup
Prep: 5 minutes active, 12–24 hours draining
Cooking: None
Pairs well with: Seedy crackers, fresh fruit, Rambleberry Compote, wildflower salad, and good wildflower honey
Note on type of yogurt: You’ll need a brand that does not contain any additional thickeners, such as carageenan or corn starch, which will keep the yogurt from draining. I’ve had great luck with the Brown Cow brand!
Ingredients:
- 2 cups plain whole milk yogurt (see note above!)
- Blue Butterfly Pea Teabags (I use this brand)
- 1/4 tsp. fine salt
- Optional: honey for drizzling
Line a small strainer with cheesecloth or a clean, thin cotton cloth. Set it over a bowl to catch the whey.
Open the teabag and stir the contents into the yogurt, along with the salt. Spoon the yogurt into the lined strainer.
Gather the cloth edges and tie into a loose pouch. Suspend (I tied mine to a cabinet pull!) and let drain over a bowl for 12–24 hours, depending on desired thickness.
Once firm and spreadable, turn the cheese out into a bowl. Serve chilled, with a drizzle of honey if desired. Cover and store in the fridge for up to a week.
I haven’t tried it yet, but the finished cheese is just asking to be infused with some floral flavors, so stay tuned as I get to trying that eventually!









